Comprendre et visualiser le calcul des notes de Renaissance

Comprendre la notation

Chaque prise de position est notée sur un barème à 5 niveaux :

  • Agit pour les animaux : qui améliore réellement le sort des animaux, fait progresser vers une réelle prise en compte de leurs intérêts.
  • Penche pour les animaux : qui tend à soutenir l’amélioration du sort des animaux, mais avec une ambition inférieure aux attentes citoyennes ou une portée incertaine.
  • Oublie les animaux : qui ne prend pas position sur l’amélioration du sort des animaux, en particulier en cas de forte attente citoyenne ou de prises de position officielles d’autres personnalités politiques.
  • Penche contre les animaux : qui tend à freiner l’amélioration du sort des animaux, par le refus explicite d'agir, par le soutien assumé au statu quo, par la reprise de certains éléments de langage des lobbies, etc.
  • Agit contre les animaux : qui s’oppose directement à l’amélioration du sort des animaux, freine concrètement la prise en compte de leurs intérêts.

Le calcul des notes thématiques et globale d'une personnalité ou d'un parti est automatisé et prend en compte l'ensemble de ses prises de position. La note d'une personnalité est calculée lorsque celle-ci a un nombre significatif de 5 prises de position. Le détail du calcul de la note d'une personnalité est consultable à partir de sa fiche en suivant le lien "Visualiser le calcul des notes".

Explication détaillée du calcul des notes des personnalités politiques et des partis

Calcul détaillé des notes de Renaissance


← Fiche
Membres
Importance médiatique
Note générale
Animaux de compagnie
Divertissement
Chasse & pêche
Mer & pisciculture
Élevage
Expérimentation
Animaux liminaires
Droit animal
Jean-Baptiste Moreau x 5 1.73 6.07 4.97 3.75 1.96 0.2 6.47
Julien Denormandie x 5 8.22 16.36 6.73 6.22 8.66 5.56 7.1
Laurence Maillart-Méhaignerie x 5 7.09 8.93 7.18 4.88 8.99 6.3 10 5.81
Christophe Castaner x 5 6.89 10.83 7.53 4.56 11.67 6.11 9.21
Alain Perea x 5 4.24 10.67 4.42 4.27 5.17 3.22 7.14
Gérard Collomb x 5 4.84 11.48 2.18 7.33 7.82 10.03 7.33
Gérald Darmanin x 5 13.39 17.86 9.01 9.41 8.1 16.02 14.26
Renaud Muselier x 5 1.99 17.24 0.88 0.85 1.12 1.15 17.7
François Patriat x 5 3.3 4.93 1.67 4.46 4.15
Pascal Canfin x 5 9.65 13.45 4.61 10.84 11.29 7.11 9.68 3.46
Gabriel Attal x 5 6.32 3.14 13.2 6.5 9.77 6.78 1.85 7.15 10
Franck Riester x 5 3.68 2.44 1.71 6.4 4.76
Loïc Dombreval x 5 16.01 19.55 17.23 18.96 16.89 13.42 18.57 19.04
Claire O'Petit x 5 17.25 19.08 16.87 19.45 13.91 15.38 18.68 19.11
Olivier Dussopt x 5 8.29 5.39 8.66
Bruno Le Maire x 5 3.31 6.57 2.11 0.91 3.73
Richard Ferrand x 5 8.2 16.15 15.12 4.49 10.92 8.13
Jean Castex x 5 4.92 16.36 4.24 2.52 4.6 7.68 1.41 4.77
Florence Berthout x 5 17.04 18.64 13.93 14.19 17.9 18.38 12.09 16.68
Alain Bertrand x 5 1.5 15.46 4.81 0.49
François de Rugy x 5 8.98 7.98 12.42 5.21 17.82 10.75 8.49
Emmanuel Macron x 5 3.88 11.4 4.62 1.85 3.24 4.24 3.46 5.88 7.06
Benjamin Griveaux x 5 11.66 15.12 11.52 5.59 7.13 12.96
Gilles Le Gendre x 5 7.87 13.26 8.54 4.38 8.93 7.04 10
Sandrine Le Feur x 5 9.01 16.41 7.83 5.62 12.34 7.37 18.27 14.72
Aurore Bergé x 5 11.51 13.86 15.96 14.92 4.43 9.79 16.12 13.57
Samantha Cazebonne x 5 17.97 18.88 19.28 18.39 17.71 16.77 18.47 15.26 16.13
Thierry Solère x 5 6.92 6.6 6.55 5.48 9.89 7.01 5.42
Stéphane Travert x 5 3.57 10.59 5.44 1.29 2.14 2.17 3.45 8.88
Éric Woerth x 5 6.71 5.56 5.6 3.87 8.26 7.52 10 5.42
Jean Arthuis x 5 1.36 3.76 0.68 0.88 3.06 1.41 3.68 0.89
Roland Lescure x 5 7.86 7.9 14.16 5.19 14.6 5.32 10
Alain Tourret 7.27 7.28 6.4 4.77 6.92 8.05 5.2
Laëtitia Romeiro Dias 16.48 19.33 16.6 19 17.3 14.02 18.35 19.16
Fiona Lazaar 8.46 7.51 7.24 6.72 9.44 8.72 5.89
Gaël Le Bohec 8.38 6.5 8.18 5.17 10.86 6.45 18
Danièle Cazarian 11.62 17.06 9.04 8.23 8.73 9.71 14.65
Florian Bachelier 6.68 6.6 7.05 5.24 7.16 6.37 5.14
Caroline Abadie 9.59 13.26 9.22 4.38 8.72 8.98 10
Hadrien Ghomi 8.96 14.18 10 3.6 1.14 7.62 10
Olivier Véran 9.43 6.59 6.88 9.17 12.96
Salima Yenbou 11.8 17.9 11.17 11.89 6.74 16.33 18.78 4.05
Philippe Sorez 10.43 19.12 3.72 3.6 9.14 10 10
Blandine Brocard 9.07 7.63 6.45 7.8 10.48 8.98 10 5.42
Laetitia Saint-Paul 9.74 13.26 8.54 6.14 5.26 7.48 16.55
Pierre Cazeneuve 11.84 18.86 10 12.77 9.14 10.4 10
Thomas Gassilloud 8.92 9.43 6.45 4.62 8.57 8.98 12.19 6.53
Jean-Luc Fugit 7.91 15.6 10.8 10.11 10.43 5.97 2.09 14.68
Benjamin Haddad 10.46 13.97 10 3.6 9.14 10 10
Guillaume Kasbarian 9.63 16.12 16.2 7.24 4.67 6.98 10 10.61
Fabienne Roumet 19.12 15.12 15.84 17.68 14.12 18 17.48 11.49 17.9
Christophe Euzet 12.72 16.7 7.17 7.02 14.74 11.36 14.96 14.96
Philippe Chalumeau 14.16 17.99 9.55 9.18 14.37 12.38 12.72
Christophe Jerretie 7.1 16.37 7.17 5.59 6.41 6.1
Anthony Cellier 9.02 17.47 8.88 6.22 18.03 6.12 12.96
Zivka Park 11.07 7.51 9.52 10.54 18.91 12.02 18.35 5.89
Philippe Huppé 6.86 7.94 5.2 4.56 9.42 5.86 14.96 6.96
Monique Iborra 9.06 10.88 10.28 4.62 8.57 8.35 10
Thomas Rudigoz 10.11 13.26 8.54 7 8.82 8.89 10 15.51 13.53
Xavier Iacovelli 15.93 16.13 17.21 17.88 16.49 13.13 18.46 13.02 13.02
Yannick Haury 10.66 16.17 10.55 6.03 8.81 8.21 18.27 13.7
Stéphane Bijoux 4.18 12.27 5.27 5.77 5.15 1.41 1.22 3.67
Chantal Bouloux 11.4 18.86 10 3.6 8.63 10.84 10
Fadila Khattabi 9.93 12.27 7.53 4.62 8.75 9.05 10 5.42
Natalia Pouzyreff 8.58 6.18 10.4 11.65 8.25 7.07 10 17.31
Annie Vidal 12.07 19.25 9.31 4.62 13.28 10.96 10
Bertrand Sorre 10.71 16.78 9.31 5.38 9.51 9.62 10 14.85
Jean-René Cazeneuve 4.8 6.09 6.43 4.03 5.3 4.42 3.45 18
Béatrice Piron 11.31 14.49 8.54 6.17 14.1 11.29 3.45 11.04
Séverine Gipson 9.05 17.72 9.04 4.62 9.96 6.05 18
Cécile Delpirou 10.16 15.12 9.04 7.69 18.53 8.73
Damien Pichereau 9.03 7.87 6.55 7.28 10.1 7.7 5.42
Danièle Hérin 6.12 6.85 7.05 5.47 16.51 4.18 7.23
Jean François Mbaye 12.99 17.05 13.02 18.35 18.02 13.86 18.35 17.31
Didier Rambaud 2.22 0.39 6.29 5.13
Cédric Roussel 11.28 8.62 9.52 12.06 9.03 10.24 18.35 9.37
Jean-Charles Colas-Roy 12.23 8.62 7.05 10.65 11.6 10.01 10.36
Anne-Laurence Petel 14.14 19.51 18.5 16.24 8.07 11.05 18.82 18.85
Emmanuel Lacresse 10.49 19.07 10 3.6 9.14 8.7 10
Dominique Da Silva 9.7 15.82 10.47 9.71 10.03 8.95 15.91 18.57
Frédéric Marchand 4.67 2.25 4.32 12.51 14.24
Laurence Heydel Grillere 10.11 13.82 13.35 1.58 9.14 10 10
Éric Gold 4.94 1.77 8.62 6.37 16.99
Stéphanie Yon-Courtin 3.79 12.27 5.87 3.21 5.85 0.95 1.22 0.62
Alexis Govciyan 17.73 18.36 15.68 17.47 16.45 17.63 12.09 16.65
Florent Boudié 8.1 8.93 7.35 2.69 8.72 8.46 10 5.6
Sandra Marsaud 6.9 8.88 5.53 10.2 4.7 5.35 10 6.33
Hervé Berville 7.17 6.6 10.59 2.36 5.72 5.74 7.15 5.42
Ludovic Mendes 9.58 9.8 6.62 4.62 9.02 8.86 10 9.08
Sylvain Maillard 9.42 11.65 6.92 4.24 7.92 8.27 10 5.42
Ludovic Haye 2.5 2.61 0.97 15.37
Yves Blein 8.41 7.46 7.05 7.56 17.56 7.83 5.42
Souad Zitouni 13.1 17.6 12.07 11.34 11.99 12.2 18.35
Martine Leguille-Balloy 5.41 9.11 16.4 5.19 7.47 3.24 11.26
Aude Bono-Vandorme 5.86 17.57 4.69 4.75 7.77 3.79
Thierry Michels 13.24 15.12 18.74 18.35 11.6 11.62 18.35 12.96
Valérie Thomas 7.57 6.6 6.55 5.59 13.04 7.72 5.42
Laurence Vanceunebrock-Mialon 14.11 13.48 9.19 10.95 11.99 12.37 14.31 16.55
Hélène Zannier 16.07 18.55 13.78 13.09 9.94 12.08 18.35 19.26
Jean-Bernard Sempastous 9.11 17.19 7.86 6.66 9.72 7.09 8.03
Quentin Bataillon 11.88 19.09 10 3.6 9.14 10 17.04
Jean-François Lovisolo 4.55 13.32 10 0.92 1.14 3.72 10
Jean-Yves Caullet 8.86 6.5 6.84 11.15 12.08
Christopher Weissberg 8.4 12.46 10 3.6 1.14 6.94 10 15.34
Lionel Causse 8.71 10.68 7.74 8.9 6.4 7.3 10 5.42
Christine Le Nabour 3.68 12.46 10 3.6 0.65 2.51 10
Didier Le Gac 4.74 9.06 7.04 3.14 3.09 4.12 10 5.42
Françoise Buffet 6.9 4.96 10 13.31 0.95 7.97 2.09 15.34
Olivia Grégoire 6.31 4.34 15.37 8.89 6.34 12.96
Astrid Panosyan-Bouvet 11.16 13.97 10 3.6 9.14 10.77 10 15.34
Antoine Armand 7.86 12.99 3.45 0.68 8.41 10.17 10
Elise Fajgeles 1.68 14.2 0.72
Anne-Laure Cattelot 9.07 11.19 9.04 6.83 8.05 7.31
Sereine Mauborgne 6.95 11.9 5.36 7.18 9.95 5.95 13.62
Fabien Gouttefarde 9.34 6.6 7.05 5.04 11.93 8.23 6.49
Didier Baichère 10 7.86 9.82 10.54 9.49 10.46 18.35 5.89
Valérie Gomez-Bassac 11.23 17.56 11.19 5.59 10.06 7.67 17.32
Christelle Dubos 8.27 16.15 9.35 7.04 11.31 4.28
Stéphanie Kerbarh 11.76 9.09 6.55 5.53 11.3 9.42 11.27
Éric Poulliat 9.42 14.49 13.38 3.6 8.57 7.89 10 10
Sarah Tanzilli 9.78 13.97 10 3.6 1.14 7.87 17.04
Michèle Peyron 8.42 14.08 9.89 4.62 1.73 5.49 10 14.04
Jean-Marc Zulesi 12.53 19.56 12.37 11.57 7.58 9.4 18.82 16.6
Alexis Izard 5.96 18.86 10 3.6 9.45 4.1 10
Ilana Cicurel 4.69 12.27 7.67 5.49 5.4 3.13 1.22 0.48
Éric Husson 10 10 10 10 10
Chrysoula Zacharopoulou 13.15 12.27 18.14 14.35 19.36 10.34 9.52 13.85
Éric Bothorel 9 19.04 12.29 3.8 11.34 6.33 10 17.31
Guillaume Gouffier Valente 10.22 15.64 8.26 4.62 9.81 9.54 10 10
Constance Le Grip 5.72 9.14 4.05 2.09 5.6 6 3.71 3.52
Patricia Mirallès 7.72 16.67 8.02 5.04 7.97 6.99
Muriel Roques-Etienne 5.53 6.6 6.55 5.04 5.44 5.45 5.42
Amal-Amélia Lakrafi 8.47 6.6 9.14 10.98 7.16 9.43 18.35 5.42
Sylvie Charrière 7.65 15.12 10.67 10.98 12.47 6.75 18.35 10.61
Valéria Faure-Muntian 13.07 18.12 12.63 5.59 8.51 7.1 17.31
Yannick Kerlogot 10.82 16.92 18.61 14.13 18.7 6.98 7.09 17.7
Stéphane Claireaux 9.24 6.6 9.47 7.54 8.79 11.16 18.35 6.25
Fabrice Le Vigoureux 10.55 13.86 11.78 9.71 9.29 9.93 15.91
Patrice Perrot 6.18 12.99 6.55 2.95 8.6 4.39 9.34 6.27
Philippe Dunoyer 9.53 8.34 6.87 4.62 8.41 9.82 10 5.42
Alain Richard 4.06 2.25 6.67 6.6 3.7
André Guiol 3.18 0.41 5.21 7.54 16.99
Fanta Berete 4.74 18.86 10 3.6 0.65 2.46 17.04
Thomas Cazenave 9.94 18.86 10 3.6 1.14 9.64 3.45 15.34
Annaïg Le Meur 5.76 10.01 8.54 4.5 5.01 4.39 10
Liliana Tanguy 6.82 6.6 10.81 10.47 10.74 5.22 3.45 12.33
Danielle Brulebois 7.79 11.65 7.35 3.08 5.69 7.04 3.45 8.17
Stéphane Mazars 6.52 12.67 7.88 5.23 8.31 6.19 10
Stéphane Séjourné 5.56 12.27 5.87 10.55 9.73 2.14 1.22 0.9
Emmanuelle Fontaine-Domeizel 7.37 12.85 3.54 7.16 7.27
Sira Sylla 10.52 8.71 7.05 6.01 10.5 10.6 6.9
Pacôme Rupin 7.34 6.5 8.18 5.59 8.82 7.37
Florence Granjus 17.41 18.32 19.13 18.91 10.96 15.23 18.35 17.92
Xavier Paluszkiewicz 8.76 8.62 7.12 7.09 7.16 7.87 6.33
Olivier Gaillard 7.57 5.42 5.15 4.41 8.89 8.87 5.42
Célia de Lavergne 5.9 7.15 7.05 5.36 11.4 3.33 9.37
Mounir Belhamiti 9.63 18.86 10 2.22 6.91 8.73 11.03
Robin Reda 9.7 11.89 7.61 5.75 8.26 7.82 17.04 6.84
Nadia Hai 9.31 13.82 10 3.6 8.57 8.42 10
Clara Chassaniol 8.1 12.46 10 3.6 1.14 5.94 10
Didier Paris 7.84 9.41 6.62 4.62 3.48 7.22 10 5.42
Sandro Gozi 4.47 12.27 2.27 7.37 6.18 2.35 1.22 0.48
Alexandre Holroyd 10.01 9.88 7.35 4.62 8.72 10.02 11.04 5.42
Yannick Chenevard 8.87 12.46 10 3.6 1.14 8.28 10
Charles Sitzenstuhl 7.82 6.17 10 15.18 1.14 8.28 3.45
Stéphane Vojetta 10.87 13.82 13.15 3.6 8.41 9.63 10 18
Jean-Michel Jacques 8.41 13.26 7.05 4.33 8.52 8.07 10 10
Sacha Houlié 10.07 14.88 9.22 3.87 10.33 9.23 10
Marc Ferracci 11.03 12.46 10 3.6 9.14 11.3 10
Vincent Ledoux 16.66 19.73 16.46 14.44 13.26 13.06 19.38 15.34 16.01
Florence Provendier 14.21 11.79 13.08 11.99 18.22 14.98 18.47 12.24
Valérie Oppelt 10.55 16.15 13.39 5.59 8.42 6.06 17.31
Lénaïck Adam 6.89 6.6 7.05 5.24 7.39 7.1 5.42
Monique Limon 5.42 7.9 8.81 5.25 8.08 2.38 18
Richard Lioger 9.7 15.12 8.18 7.69 11.86 5.81
Raphaël Gauvain 9.52 7.85 9.04 5.59 6.43 6.33 18.4
Mounir Mahjoubi 9.8 6.6 9.14 10.98 19 11.21 18.35 5.42
Bruno Questel 11 15.12 10.45 5.04 15.2 6.28 14.04
Laurence Cristol 10.67 18.86 7.66 2.55 9.14 10 10
Louis Margueritte 9.24 13.82 7.66 2.48 9.14 8.9 10
Rémy Rebeyrotte 4.89 15.32 5.95 4.98 3.26 2.47 10 13.53
Brigitte Bourguignon 7.76 5.24 9.91 5.42
Jacqueline Maquet 9.2 9.87 7.94 3.74 10.01 9.32 10 5.41
Jérémy Decerle 2.86 12.27 0.48 5.23 5.04 0.21 1.22 0.61
Claire Guichard 6.96 18.86 13.35 3.6 1.14 4.98 10
Bernard Buis 1.66 0.39 3.2 3.39
Céline Calvez 10.99 10.4 10.12 10.33 8.75 10.19 10
Jean Terlier 7.96 14.87 8.54 3.97 4.92 7.62 3.45
Corinne Vignon 16.3 18.9 17.46 18.46 11.91 13.45 19.37 16.03
Yaël Braun-Pivet 10.48 17.76 12.13 9.36 5.76 9.94 15.91
Charles Rodwell 6.87 7.09 10 15.18 6.49 5.39 10
Maud Bregeon 9.29 12.46 10 3.6 8.41 8.95 10
Grégory Galbadon 9 5.8 9.71 5.76
Michèle Crouzet 5.06 7.15 6.02 5.59 11.31 3.6 4.96
Marie-Christine Verdier-Jouclas 7.81 15.12 5.36 5.46 8.5 5.95 13.82
Jean-François Eliaou 6.8 6.5 8.88 5.01 7.77 6.22
Pierre Cabaré 13.27 10.97 12.87 12.24 8.51 13.15 18.35 12.72
Bénédicte Peyrol 7.52 15.12 8.18 5.59 7.77 6.04 6.45
Typhanie Degois 17.38 11.31 13.65 19.21 19.2 18.46 18.65 11.33
Raphaël Gérard 6.68 12.08 7.1 4.62 8.08 5.02 10 5.42
Jean-Pierre Pont 9.91 8.93 6.86 4.19 10.12 8.97 10 9.95
Michel Dagbert 14.87 15.07 8.7 15.68 14.79 16.64 16.29
Anne Brugnera 10.59 11.1 8.37 5.74 13.46 9.9 10 5.42
Nadège Havet 13.25 14.08 15.97 4.31 6.09 5.65
Philippe Emmanuel 3.21 10 7.54 2.55 10
Marie Guévenoux 9.89 9.99 7.35 4.62 8.57 9.93 10 5.42
Caroline Yadan 12.08 18.86 13.35 15.18 9.14 10 10
Jean-Carles Grelier 8.07 8.89 5.8 4.33 8.26 7.99 10 4.58
Laure Miller 8.07 17.27 10 2.19 1.14 6.32 18.27
Daniel Labaronne 7.75 11.68 6.7 11.78 3.78 6.23 3.45 7.25
Nicolas Metzdorf 7.6 19 10 2.55 1.14 5.19 10
Anne Genetet 9.62 13.53 9.95 3.6 8.72 9.13 10 10.81
Hervé Pellois 7.19 7.47 7.8 3.72 12.56 9.31 6.62
Adrien Morenas 11.66 14.23 2.15 12.1 12.8
Grégory Besson-Moreau 4.95 16.28 5.59 4.36 12.11 3.57 13.62
Jacqueline Dubois 10.89 16.08 10.85 6.92 9.47 5.7 15.76
Benoit Potterie 3.8 16.67 8.11 4.85 6.88 2.68 7.32 4.77
Nicole Trisse 14.65 18.2 12.37 12.23 10.85 11.41 18.47 16.73
Catherine Fabre 8.08 7.52 8.1 15.92 7.16 5.81 5.42
Caroline Janvier 9.76 10.4 8.86 7.18 9.22 9.08 10 8.44
Frédéric Descrozaille 6.08 12.4 7.35 4.35 6.3 3.81 10 6.47
Jean-François Cesarini 12.59 12.85 6.37 10.67 12 14.43
Charlotte Goetschy-Bolognese 8.83 13.82 10 3.6 1.14 5.94 10
Benoît Bordat 11.73 19.42 14.55 9.51 11.37 8.06 18.59 15.69 15.34
Bernard Guetta 7.72 12.27 7.67 3.21 11.77 2.71 1.22 3.67
Claire Colomb-Pitollat 5.64 11.65 6.92 3.94 7.17 4.37 10 5.42
Jean-François Rousset 9.65 12.46 10 2.93 9.14 9.59 10
Belkhir Belhaddad 8.07 8.93 7.35 4.94 3.48 7.65 3.45 9.08
Graziella Melchior 5.88 15.66 9.31 4.29 11 5.33 3.45
Eléonore Caroit 12.91 15.28 10 10 11.81 12.63 15.34
Michel Lauzzana 10.5 15.87 10.54 5.59 3.48 7.85 10 17.49
Thani Mohamed Soilihi 5.01 2.25 6.67 12.57 6.62
Patrick Loiseau 6.41 7.52 5.79 5.59 7.05 5.42
Rodrigue Kokouendo 8.36 6.85 6.55 5.59 11.04 7.87 5.42
Marc Delatte 9.8 16.65 9.89 5.59 9.71 7.16
Anne-France Brunet 9.3 7.15 9.87 10.84 12.12 9.29 18.35 5.96
Michel Delpon 8.45 7.15 7.05 5.59 11.91 7.62 5.42
Carole Bureau-Bonnard 8.57 17.42 9.04 5.43 16.61 6.76 15.76
Brune Poirson 11.59 15.12 10.05 10.98 11.08 16.71 18.45
Patrick Vignal 10.42 16.02 8.63 8.82 9.63 10.28 15.91 14.26
Mireille Clapot 11.09 15.7 12.27 11.04 11.82 9.76 15.91
Servane Hugues 10.35 12.46 10 2.93 10 10.63 10
Lysiane Métayer 11.56 19.07 10 3.6 8.59 10 17.04
Pierre Karleskind 5.47 12.27 5.27 7.58 7.31 1.92 1.22 3.67
Patricia Lemoine 12.29 16.42 12.09 8.11 11.1 10.35 12.19 17.71
Christophe Marion 7.73 19.12 10 8.89 6.91 7.11 3.45
Stéphanie Rist 11 15.3 11.82 10.81 8.9 9.97 15.91 12.96
Stéphane Buchou 8.75 14.08 9.22 4.92 6.88 8.24 3.45 14.97
Julie Delpech 9.33 12.46 14.91 3.6 9.14 9.59 3.45
Prisca Thevenot 7.81 7.09 10 15.18 1.14 7.21 3.45
Camille Galliard-Minier 10.48 15.12 9.04 5.59 16.29 9.11
Gilles Pargneaux 3.3 7.06 7.77 0.87 4.49 2.36 1.2 1.01
Barbara Bessot Ballot 9.85 17.2 9.04 5.04 11.49 5.91 14.75
Mickaël Nogal 9 7.15 9.14 10.98 6.88 10.05 18.35 5.42
Buon Tan 6.59 6.6 6.55 5.59 7.16 6.37 5.42
Cathy Racon-Bouzon 10.02 6.5 8.18 5.59 10.22 8.55 16.91
Dominique David 10.08 15.12 8.04 5.59 11.53 6.22 17.31
Anne Blanc 7.69 7.15 7.13 4.76 10.52 6.19 5.42
Claire Bouchet 8.76 6.5 9.04 5.59 18.7 9.01
Didier Martin 6.81 11.66 6.79 5.28 7.83 3.74 10 10.83
Benoit Mournet 9.87 13.82 7.66 1.24 9.14 10.77 10
Jean-Philippe Ardouin 9.3 16.17 9.98 6.12 6.21 6.44 17.86 16.6
Michel Dennemont 3.32 2.25 4.32
Christine Decodts 12.71 15.12 10 2.19 13.2 13.35 10
Jean-Baptiste Lemoyne 4.51 5.24 2.26 5.19
Didier Parakian 10 10 10 10 10
Sabrina Agresti-Roubache 10.09 12.46 10 3.6 9.14 10 10
Véronique Riotton 10.26 14.79 8.54 4.1 10.16 9.54 18.27
Nicole Le Peih 3.39 11.8 6.92 4.16 4.28 2.04 3.45 5.42
Anthony Brosse 6.42 18.86 13.79 2.19 1.14 5.68 4.06
Mikaele Seo 10.91 12.46 10 3.6 9.14 11.12 10
Paul Midy 12.64 12.46 10 3.6 9.45 13.59 10
Gwendal Rouillard 5.34 6.6 6.55 4.07 5.12 6.02 5.42
Marie Silin 6.02 6.6 6.55 5.59 16.29 6 5.42
Coralie Dubost 10.15 7.86 9.63 10.98 9.71 10.89 18.35 5.42
Sébastien Cazenove 8.03 8.73 7.57 5.04 9.71 6.59 5.42
Nicolas Démoulin 6.47 16.67 9.35 5.04 11.86 2.76 10
Christophe Di Pompeo 8.2 15.12 9.04 5.59 7.16 6.37
Jean-Claude Leclabart 6.21 15.12 10.45 4.21 9.23 3.7 9.22
Fannette Charvier 9.56 10.58 9.04 5.97 8.51 8.28 12.96
Pascale Boyer 7.83 19.44 9.22 4.59 6.79 5.04 10 17.75
Huguette Tiegna 8.8 15.07 11.75 4.31 10.38 6.52 10 15.77
Émilie Chandler 12.9 19.07 14.91 3.6 9.14 11.3 10 15.34
Véronique Trillet-Lenoir 6.27 12.27 2.27 7.28 8.68 4.53 1.22 0.9
Philippe Guillemard 11.55 14.46 10 3.6 9.69 10 17.04
Valérie Hayer 4.09 12.27 5.27 7.58 5.15 1.25 1.22 0.58
Hanna Sebbah 17.73 18.36 15.68 17.47 16.45 17.63 12.09 16.65
David Amiel 10.91 6.17 10 15.18 9.14 12.55 10
Nicole Dubré-Chirat 10.57 12.57 7.11 8.52 8.34 8.07 10 9.08
Benjamin Dirx 8.27 6.22 7.35 4.36 9.29 9.09 10 5.42
Denis Masséglia 7.08 12.66 6.99 4.24 6.19 4.93 3.45 6.06
Marie Lebec 5.65 5.36 13.46 13.82 4.83 3.91 10
Laurent Saint-Martin 7.66 7.16 8.81 5.59 7.16 6.21 10
Jacques Krabal 6.25 17.06 7.56 3.43 7.77 6.65 6.62
Jean-Michel Fauvergue 6.97 6.6 7.05 5.59 7.16 6.37 5.42
Pierre Person 6.84 6.6 9.14 11.96 16.12 6.17 18.35 5.42
Christine Cloarec 8.12 6.6 7.05 5.59 13.42 7.84 5.42
Alice Thourot 13.25 13.98 12.7 12.4 14.14 11.79 18.47 17.49
Pascal Bois 11.42 16.65 9.92 5.24 12.1 9.05 13.13
Noëlle Rauscent 4.31 12.85 3.82 3.27
Fabienne Colboc 9.85 19.27 10.25 9 12.59 7.44 17.04 12.81
Damien Adam 12.53 15.73 17.38 11.6 12.61 11.53 15.91 18.15
Marjolaine Meynier-Millefert 11.33 12.1 9.38 10.1 4.12 10.79 15.91 9.28
Bérangère Couillard 9.44 16.91 9.26 4.78 7.77 9.13 11.43 12.96
Emmanuel Pellerin 3.33 12.46 10 6.09 0.73 1.6 10
Irène Tolleret 4.76 12.27 7.27 6.21 5.78 2.34 1.22 0.88
Véronique de Montchalin 4 10 10 3.38 10
Sophie Panonacle 9.84 9.41 6.99 4.66 10.16 10.65 7.23 7.69
Brigitte Liso 9.41 8.73 7.88 4.62 9.7 9.09 17.04
Olivier Becht 11.49 16.7 11.55 10.98 9.92 10.78 18.58 15.9
Jean-Marie Fiévet 9.61 12.9 10.68 4.25 10.03 9.5 3.45
Olga Givernet 7.68 11.65 7.35 4.62 7.02 6.3 10 5.42
Jean-Jacques Bridey 4.98 15.12 8.04 5.24 7.84 3.41 10
Christophe Lejeune 6.81 15.12 8.18 5.59 6.41 5.62
Mustapha Laabid 6.39 6.6 6.55 5.59 7.04 6.03 5.41
Laetitia Avia 10.12 8.72 12.87 10.54 7.16 10.57 18.35
Catherine Kamowski 5.54 15.12 8.18 5.47 9.45 2.75 18
Audrey Dufeu 7.69 8.49 7.05 5.59 7.16 6.06 5.42
Laurence Gayte 8.61 10.33 9.89 7.71 7.77 6.06 16.28
Nicolas Pacquot 6.49 14.77 10 1.76 0.95 4.99 17.04
Bruno Studer 8.96 8.93 9.22 8.55 5.7 8.03 15.91 9.08
Pascal Lavergne 3.64 12.79 7.33 3.6 0.58 2.22 10 12.96
André Gattolin 8.77 2.25 11.11 14.07 14.07 11.45
Joël Giraud 9.71 15.38 13.39 2.19 4.65 8.67 10 6.62
Martin Lévrier 4.94 4.5 6.67 5.65
Alexandra Martin 10.45 10 10 10 10 15.34
Stanislas Guerini 8.2 15.12 9.04 5.59 7.16 6.37
Amélia Lakrafi 11.54 12.46 15.32 15.18 9.14 10 10
François Cormier-Bouligeon 6.59 13.26 12.66 7.57 8.6 6 10
Violette Spillebout 11.67 15.74 13.79 3.6 9.14 10 17.04
Pieyre-Alexandre Anglade 9.26 8.93 7.35 4.62 6.96 9.02 10 5.42
Karl Olive 12.37 15.17 12.75 11.31 9.14 10 18.33 15.71 16.83
Élisabeth Borne 5.3 13.73 4.12 1.76 1.55 6.52 7.19
Jean-Louis Touraine 12.74 18.38 13.11 12.09 13.96 10.43 18.53 14.77
Sylvain Templier 12.47 10.09 16.5 12.26 18.05 12.46 15.43
Christine Hennion 5.81 7.9 11.19 5.59 10.92 3.13 10
Marie-Ange Magne 6.76 6.6 6.55 5.59 7.16 6.69 5.42
Émilie Guerel 16.02 18.4 12.8 12.79 13.92 14.43 18.35 12.71 16.51
Alexandra Valetta Ardisson 15.3 18.33 14.19 11.7 12.47 13.7 18.66 14.85
Mireille Robert 8.07 7.16 15.39 13.05 10.32 6.03
Philippe Chassaing 9.32 16.67 9.04 6.33 7.16 6.37 12.96
Lionel Royer-Perreaut 9.41 12.46 10 3.6 1.14 7.51 17.04 15.71 13.27
Éric Girardin 3.75 10.69 9.22 4 3.47 2.44 10 14.97
Guillaume Vuilletet 11.77 15.57 10.81 4.62 9.68 10.56 11.03 17.31
Julien Bargeton 13.81 11.82 15.52 18.35 18.99 14.83
Carole Grandjean 10.28 16.42 9.04 5.59 9.71 8.26 15.59
Nicole Duranton 10.47 17.54 16.6 0.63 12.07 5.42 5.71
Fabienne Keller 5.49 12.27 2.22 7.15 7.75 3.17 1.22 0.62
Catherine Ibled 17.73 18.36 15.68 17.47 16.45 17.63 12.09 16.65
Marie-Pierre Rixain 9.9 10.4 11.78 9.71 8.72 9.94 15.91